| Year | Champion | Site |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Thomas Finn | Bethpage - Black |
| 2022 | Charlie Berridge | Bethpage - Black |
| 2021 | Ben Pirro | Bethpage - Black |
| 2020 | Kyle Ritchie | Bethpage - Black |
| 2019 | Keith Hendrickson | Bethpage - Black |
| 2018 | Kevin Talty* | Bethpage - Black |
| 2017 | Gerry Mackedon | Bethpage - Black |
| 2016 | Kyle Brey | Bethpage - Black |
| 2015 | Bradley Rock, Jr.* | Bethpage - Black |
| 2014 | Michael Guli* | Bethpage - Black |
| 2013 | Garett Engel | Bethpage - Black |
| 2012 | Edward Gibstein* | Bethpage - Black |
| 2011 | Colin Dolph | Bethpage - Black |
| 2010 | David Jankowski | Bethpage - Black |
*Determined by a playoff