| Year | Champion | Site |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Mimi McAndrew | Bethpage – Red |
| 2023 | Ina Kim-Schaad | Bethpage – Red |
| 2022 | Caraline Oakley | Bethpage – Red |
| 2021 | Danielle Bambola | Bethpage – Red |
| 2020 | Not played | |
| 2019 | Jennifer Rosenberg | Bethpage – Blue |
| 2018 | Nabila Inak | Bethpage – Red |
| 2017 | Carly Peters | Bethpage – Red |
| 2016 | Danielle Greene | Bethpage – Red |
| 2015 | Caroline Araskog | Bethpage – Red |
| 2014 | Dani Mullen | Bethpage – Red |
| 2013 | Marie Santacroce* | Bethpage – Red |
| 2012 | Marie Santacroce | Bethpage – Red |
| 2011 | Harin Lee | Bethpage – Red |
| 2010 | Chloe Altchek | Bethpage – Red |
| 2009 | Lois Kim | Bethpage – Red |
| 2008 | Michele Romano | Bethpage – Red |
| 2007 | Susannah Aboff | Bethpage – Red |
| 2006 | Paula Moskwik | Bethpage – Red |
| 2005 | Susan Choi | Bethpage – Red |
| 2004 | Lee Ann Lewis | Bethpage – Red |
| 2003 | Not played | |
| 2002 | Amy Lane | Bethpage – Red |
| 2001 | Lee Ann Vogel | Bethpage – Yellow |
| 2000 | Debra Nowicki* | Bethpage – Green |
| 1999 | Lee Ann Vogel | Bethpage – Green |
*Determined by a playoff
