| Year | Champion | Site |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Alan Specht | Old Westbury |
| 2022 | David Boccia | Old Westbury |
| 2021 | David Boccia | Old Westbury |
| 2020 | Dave Scialabba | Old Westbury |
| 2019 | Edwards Gibstein | Old Westbury |
| 2018 | Drew Fonrose | Old Westbury |
| 2017 | David Prowler | Old Westbury |
| 2016 | Tom Trakoval | Old Westbury |
| 2015 | Tom Trakoval | Old Westbury |
| 2014 | Tom Trakoval | Old Westbury |
| 2013 | David Prowler | Old Westbury |
| 2012 | Andy Anello | Old Westbury |
| 2011 | Andy Anello | Old Westbury |
| 2010 | Marty Winkelman | Old Westbury |
| 2009 | Doug Vergith | Old Westbury |
| 2008 | Marty Winkelman | Old Westbury |
| 2007 | Steve Rose | Old Westbury |
| 2006 | Alan Finkelstein | Old Westbury |
| 2005 | Steve Rose | Old Westbury |
| 2004 | Bob Stuart | Old Westbury |
| 2003 | Steve Rose | Old Westbury |
| 2002 | Gerald Garber | Old Westbury |
| 2001 | John Baldwin | Old Westbury |
| 2000 | John Baldwin | Old Westbury |
| 1999 | Alan Gilison | Old Westbury |
| 1998 | Mark Stuart, Jr.** | Old Westbury |
| 1997 | Alan Gilison** | Old Westbury |
| 1996 | Jack Pierce** | Old Westbury |
| 1995 | Morty Howard | Old Westbury |
| 1994 | John French | Old Westbury |
| 1993 | Jerry Loeber | Fresh Meadow |
| 1992 | Bob Shields | Oyster Bay |
| 1991 | Jerry Loeber | Woodmere |
| 1990 | Robert Hooper | Towers |
| 1989 | Eugene Holmes | Rockville Links |
| 1988 | Eugene Holmes | St. George’s |
| 1987 | Jerry Loeber | Fox Hills |
| 1986 | Robert Shields | St. George’s |
| 1985 | Morty Howard | North Shore |
| 1984 | Jim Tingley | Glen Oaks |
| 1983 | Morty Howard | Huntington Crescent |
| 1982 | Dick Remsen | Engineers |
| 1981 | Mike Mattwell | Glen Oaks |
| 1980 | Mal Galletta | Glen Oaks |
| 1979 | Dick Remsen | Glen Oaks |
| 1978 | Jack Parker | Glen Oaks |
| 1977 | Jack Parker | Glen Oaks |
| 1976 | Jesse Harris | Glen Oaks |
** Match of Cards
| Old Westbury |
| Old Westbury |
